Updated November 2026

A honda riding lawn mower won’t start for a few common reasons, and a worn starter is one of the most frequent culprits. This guide compares five replacement starter parts sold on Amazon US, grouped by what they are built to do. Selection criteria: listing clarity about the Honda model fit, the part number cross-references, the starter type (electric motor or recoil), and recurring owner feedback about fit and durability. None of these have been tested by us.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1SCITOO Starters 18350TOP CHOICEBest overallSCITOO Starters 18350View on Amazon
  2. 2SCITOO Starter Motor (OEM# 028000-8410)TOP CHOICEBest for OEM part-number matchingSCITOO Starter Motor (OEM# 028000-8410)View on Amazon
  3. 3Hoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil StarterTOP CHOICEBest for pull-start enginesHoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil StarterView on Amazon
  4. 428400-Z8B-902 Recoil Starter AssemblyBest for recoil replacement on HRX/HRS models28400-Z8B-902 Recoil Starter AssemblyView on Amazon
  5. 5Rareelectrical 10-Tooth StarterBest for GXV-series enginesRareelectrical 10-Tooth StarterView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
SCITOO Starters 18350 Best overall Electric starter, multiple Honda cross-references
SCITOO Starter Motor (OEM# 028000-8410) OEM part-number matching Listed against Honda 31200 numbers
Hoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil Starter Pull-start engines Recoil assembly for HRR-series
28400-Z8B-902 Recoil Starter Assembly HRX/HRS recoil replacement Direct replacement part number
Rareelectrical 10-Tooth Starter GXV-series engines 10-tooth CCW drive, 12V

SCITOO Starters 18350

SCITOO Starters 18350 fit Riding Lawn Mower Tractor for Honda 3813 31200-ZA0-701 31200-ZA1-003

SCITOO Starters 18350 fit Riding Lawn Mower Tractor for Honda 3813 31200-ZA0-701 31200-ZA1-003

View on Amazon

Best for: Best overall

This is a good fit for owners who want an electric starter motor matched to a range of Honda tractor and mower part numbers.

Pros

  • Lists several Honda 31200 cross-reference numbers
  • Common replacement choice for electric-start riders

Cons

  • Confirm your engine’s part number before ordering

View on Amazon

SCITOO Starter Motor (OEM# 028000-8410)

SCITOOFor TractorFor Honda 3813 31200-ZA0-701 31200-ZA1-003|Starters Motor|OEM# 028000-8410 Starter Fit For Riding Lawn Mower 18350N

SCITOOFor TractorFor Honda 3813 31200-ZA0-701 31200-ZA1-003|Starters Motor|OEM# 028000-8410 Starter Fit For Riding Lawn Mower 18350N

View on Amazon

Best for: OEM part-number matching

Suited to owners who prefer to match the old starter by its stamped OEM number rather than by model name.

Pros

  • OEM number listed in the title for easy comparison
  • Cross-referenced to Honda 3813 part numbers

Cons

  • Listing wording is dense, so check the fitment table carefully

View on Amazon

Hoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil Starter

Hoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil Starter, Replacement for Honda HRR2169PKA HRR2169VKA HRR216K9PKAA HRR216K9VKAA Lawn Mower Engines Lawn Mower Pressure Washer

Hoypeyfiy Pull Start Recoil Starter, Replacement for Honda HRR2169PKA HRR2169VKA HRR216K9PKAA HRR216K9VKAA Lawn Mower Engines Lawn Mower Pressure Washer

View on Amazon

Best for: Pull-start engines

Intended for owners whose Honda engine uses a pull cord rather than an electric starter, especially on HRR-series models.

Pros

  • Listed against several HRR2169 and HRR216 model numbers
  • Straightforward bolt-on recoil replacement

Cons

  • Not a fit for electric-start mowers

View on Amazon

28400-Z8B-902 Recoil Starter Assembly

28400-Z8B-902ZB Lawn Mower Engine Recoil Starter Assembly, Replacement for HRX217 HRS216K5 HRR216K9, Replaces 28400-Z8B-902ZB

28400-Z8B-902ZB Lawn Mower Engine Recoil Starter Assembly, Replacement for HRX217 HRS216K5 HRR216K9, Replaces 28400-Z8B-902ZB

View on Amazon

Best for: HRX/HRS recoil replacement

A direct replacement for owners who already have the 28400-Z8B-902 number on the old assembly. A related read: 6 Best Riding Lawn Mowers With Plow for Snow and Slopes (2026).

Pros

  • Clear OEM number match
  • Covers HRX217, HRS216 and HRR216 applications

Cons

  • Limited to recoil-start engines

View on Amazon

Rareelectrical 10-Tooth Starter

Rareelectrical10-Tooth, CCW, riding mower lawn tractor, Honda GXV340 GXV390 vertical-shaft engine, 6 lbs, replaces 31200ZF5L32, OHV 12V Pmdd Starter Fits Honda H1011 H2013 H2113 31200-Zf5-L32

Rareelectrical10-Tooth, CCW, riding mower lawn tractor, Honda GXV340 GXV390 vertical-shaft engine, 6 lbs, replaces 31200ZF5L32, OHV 12V Pmdd Starter Fits Honda H1011 H2013 H2113 31200-Zf5-L32

View on Amazon

Best for: GXV-series engines

Aimed at owners of riding mowers with the GXV340 or GXV390 vertical-shaft engine who need a 12V electric starter.

Pros

  • 10-tooth counterclockwise drive, as listed
  • Lists several Honda H-series and 31200 cross-references

Cons

  • Older listing, so verify the drive direction on your engine

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm the engine model and starter type

Check the engine label for the model code, such as GCV160 or GXV340, before comparing parts. Electric starters and recoil starters are not interchangeable.

Match the OEM or cross-reference number

Remove the old starter and read the stamped number. Compare it against the fitment list in each listing rather than relying on the title alone.

Check the drive tooth count and rotation

Electric starters use a toothed drive that must engage the flywheel ring gear. Mismatched tooth counts or rotation can cause clicking without cranking.

Consider voltage and mounting

Most Honda riding mower starters run on 12V. Confirm the bolt pattern and wiring connector before ordering.

Good picks for this: SCITOO Starters 18350 and Rareelectrical 10-Tooth Starter

FAQ

Why does my Honda riding mower click but not crank?

A click with no cranking usually points to a weak battery, poor battery cable connections, or a failing starter solenoid or motor. Test battery voltage first, since a starter cannot turn over on low power.

Can I replace a Honda recoil starter with an electric starter?

Not without changing the engine and mounting hardware. Recoil and electric starters use different parts, so stick to the starter type your engine was built with.

Colin Foster

About Colin Foster

Colin Foster is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.