Updated November 2026

When a Murray self propelled lawn mower won’t start, the recoil starter is one of the most common failure points, and replacing it is often a practical fix. This guide compares five replacement recoil starters and one starter solenoid based on listing details, model compatibility, brand reputation and common owner feedback. Selection criteria were model-number fit, clear part numbers, and how well each listing describes what it replaces.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Recoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03TOP CHOICEBest overallRecoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03View on Amazon
  2. 2Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull StarterTOP CHOICEBest for a direct model matchMurray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull StarterView on Amazon
  3. 3Pull Recoil Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12B-A0BE758TOP CHOICEBest for the 12B model seriesPull Recoil Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12B-A0BE758View on Amazon
  4. 4Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn MowersBest for an electrical no-crank problemMurray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn MowersView on Amazon
  5. 5Replacement Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 11A-A1BF758 Lawn MowerBest for the 11A seriesReplacement Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 11A-A1BF758 Lawn MowerView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Recoil Pull Starter, Model 12A-A03Z758 (MNA153003 replacement) Overall replacement Cross-referenced part number
Murray 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull Starter Direct model match Listed for the exact model
Pull Recoil Starter, Model 12B-A0BE758 12B model series Matches 12B-series housing
Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid No-crank electrical issues Solenoid replacement only
Pull Recoil Starter, Model 11A-A1BF758 11A-series mowers Smooth rewind pull action

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758, Replacement for Murray MNA153003

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758, Replacement for Murray MNA153003

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758, Replacement for Murray MNA153003

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall replacement

This suits owners who want a cross-referenced part and are checking their engine model before ordering.

Pros

  • Lists a cross-reference to MNA153003
  • Specifies the 12A-A03Z758 model

Cons

  • Fit depends on confirming your exact model number

View on Amazon

Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull Starter

For Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull Starter

For Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 Recoil Pull Starter

View on Amazon

Best for: Direct model match

A good fit for owners whose mower plate reads 12A-A03Z758 and who want the listing to name the model directly.

Pros

  • Model named in the title for easy matching
  • Straightforward recoil starter replacement

Cons

  • Limited to the one model series listed

View on Amazon

Pull Recoil Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12B-A0BE758

for Pull Recoil Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12B-A0BE758

for Pull Recoil Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12B-A0BE758

View on Amazon

Best for: 12B model series

Intended for owners with a 12B-series Murray whose original starter has cracked or stopped retracting.

Pros

  • Built for the 12B-A0BE758 designation
  • Clear model-specific title

Cons

  • Not interchangeable with 12A-series units

View on Amazon

Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn Mowers

Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn Mowers

Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn Mowers

View on Amazon

Best for: No-crank electrical issues

This is for mowers where the engine doesn’t crank at all, and you hear a click or nothing when the key is turned.

Pros

  • Targets the electrical starting circuit rather than the recoil rope
  • Relatively simple swap for a mechanically inclined owner

Cons

  • Won’t help if the recoil rope itself is broken

View on Amazon

Replacement Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 11A-A1BF758 Lawn Mower

Replacement Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 11A-A1BF758 Lawn Mower, Smooth Rewind Pull Start for Lawn Mowing and Yard Care

Replacement Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 11A-A1BF758 Lawn Mower, Smooth Rewind Pull Start for Lawn Mowing and Yard Care

View on Amazon

Best for: 11A-series mowers

Best for owners with an 11A-A1BF758 model who want a smooth rewind action after replacement.

Pros

  • Names the 11A-A1BF758 model clearly
  • Marketed for smooth rewind

Cons

  • Narrow fit outside the 11A series

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm your exact model number

Murray model numbers are usually printed on a decal near the deck or engine. Matching the full designation, such as 12A-A03Z758 or 12B-A0BE758, matters more than matching the mower brand alone.

Decide whether the rope or the electrical system failed

If the recoil rope pulls freely with no resistance, the starter is likely the problem. If you hear a click but the engine won’t turn over, the solenoid is a more likely suspect.

Check for cross-reference part numbers

Listings that cite an older part number, such as MNA153003, help confirm the replacement fits. Compare the listed reference against the number on your original part before ordering.

Consider the rewind mechanism

Owners often report that a smooth rewind makes the starter easier to use over time. Look for listings that describe the pull action and recoil spring.

Good picks for this: Recoil Pull Starter for Murray Self Propelled Lawn Mower Model 12A-A03Z758 and Murray 7701100MA Starter Solenoid for Lawn Mowers

FAQ

Why won’t my Murray self propelled mower start even though the engine turns over?

If the engine cranks but won’t fire, the problem is usually fuel, spark, or air rather than the starter itself. A recoil starter that feels loose, spins freely, or won’t engage the engine is more likely the culprit when you pull the rope with no engine movement at all.

How do I know if I need a new recoil starter or just a new rope?

If the rope is frayed, broken, or stretched, replacing the rope alone may solve the problem. If the rope retracts poorly, the handle comes off, or the pawls and spring do not engage, the full starter assembly is usually the better choice.

Do I need to match my exact model number when buying a replacement starter?

Yes, matching the model number is the safest approach because Murray mowers share similar-looking starters that differ in mounting holes, pulley size, and spring tension. Check the label on your mower deck or engine and compare it to the listing’s part numbers before ordering.

What is the difference between a recoil starter and a starter solenoid?

A recoil starter is the manual pull-rope assembly that turns the engine over by hand. A starter solenoid is an electrical component used on some electric-start mowers to send power to the starter motor, so it applies only if your mower has an electric start feature.

Can I install a replacement recoil starter myself?

Most homeowners with basic hand tools can replace a recoil starter by removing the old assembly and bolting in the new one. Disconnect the spark plug wire first, and consult your owner’s manual for torque specifications and any engine-specific steps.

Should I also check the fuel and spark plug before replacing the starter?

Yes, a quick check of the fuel, air filter, and spark plug can save time and money. Many no-start problems are caused by stale fuel or a fouled plug, so ruling those out first helps confirm that the starter is actually the issue.

Conclusion

If you know your exact Murray model number and need a direct replacement, choose the starter listed for that model, since it offers the best chance of a clean fit. If the rope is the only problem, a rope-and-pulley style replacement may be enough, while a complete recoil assembly suits owners who see the starter itself failing.

For owners who are unsure of the failure, confirm the model number and check fuel and spark first before buying a part. Once the cause is clear, the right starter or solenoid should get your Murray mower running again.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.