Updated November 2026

A briggs and stratton 500e series lawn mower won’t start for several reasons, and a worn or broken recoil starter is one of the most common. This list compares five recoil starter assemblies sold on Amazon US for the 450E, 500E and related Briggs and Stratton engines. Selection criteria were product listing details, compatibility with the engine family, the part numbers each listing cross-references, and patterns in owner feedback about fit and durability.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex SeriesTOP CHOICEBest overall593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex SeriesView on Amazon
  2. 208P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200,TOP CHOICEBest for Troy-Bilt and Craftsman mowers08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200,View on Amazon
  3. 3591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc EngineTOP CHOICEBest for Husqvarna and multi-brand fit591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc EngineView on Amazon
  4. 4Replacement for Briggs Stratton 08P502 093J02 09P602 Engines 593961 59Best for a direct engine replacementReplacement for Briggs Stratton 08P502 093J02 09P602 Engines 593961 59View on Amazon
  5. 5Upgraded Recoil Pull Starter Compatible for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500Best for larger 21-inch decksUpgraded Recoil Pull Starter Compatible for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 Overall replacement Broad 450E–550EX cross-reference
08P502 093J02 Pull Start Assembly Troy-Bilt and Craftsman mowers Lists Troy-Bilt and Craftsman models
591139 Recoil Starter 140cc Husqvarna and multi-brand fit Covers 575EX and 140cc engines
Briggs Stratton 08P502 Replacement Direct engine swap Matches original part numbers
Upgraded Recoil Pull Starter by Goodicare 21-inch deck engines Covers 600E and 625E models

593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series

593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engine Lawn Mower, Replace 595355 590588 593961

593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engine Lawn Mower, Replace 595355 590588 593961

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall replacement for the 500E series.

This is a good starting point for owners who want one part that cross-references the most engine numbers in the family, including the 590588 and 595355 replacements.

Pros

  • Lists many compatible part numbers
  • Clear cross-reference to original Briggs part numbers

Cons

  • Confirm your engine model before ordering

View on Amazon

08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200, Craftsman M110/M115 Mowers Pull Start Assembly

08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200, Craftsman M110/M115 Mowers Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX

08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200, Craftsman M110/M115 Mowers Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX

View on Amazon

Best for: Troy-Bilt and Craftsman mowers built on this engine.

Owners of Troy-Bilt or Craftsman mowers that use a 500E-family engine often find this listing easier to match to their machine.

Pros

  • Lists Troy-Bilt and Craftsman model numbers
  • Includes several Briggs engine part numbers

Cons

  • Fit depends heavily on the mower brand and model

View on Amazon

591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine

591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine, Pull Start for Troy-Bilt TB100 TB110 TB200, Husqvarna LC221A HU550FH HU625AWD, Craftsman M105 M110 M210 Lawn Mower

591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine, Pull Start for Troy-Bilt TB100 TB110 TB200, Husqvarna LC221A HU550FH HU625AWD, Craftsman M105 M110 M210 Lawn Mower

View on Amazon

Best for: Husqvarna and multi-brand compatibility.

This assembly suits owners whose mower carries a Husqvarna or Craftsman badge but runs a Briggs engine in the 140cc range.

Pros

  • Covers the 575EX and 140cc engines
  • Lists several mower brands

Cons

  • Broad compatibility means matching the part number is still essential

View on Amazon

Replacement for Briggs Stratton 08P502 093J02 09P602 Engines 593961 591139 590588 Recoil Pull Starter

Replacement for Briggs Stratton 08P502 093J02 09P602 Engines 593961 591139 590588 591139 Recoil Pull Starter

Replacement for Briggs Stratton 08P502 093J02 09P602 Engines 593961 591139 590588 591139 Recoil Pull Starter

View on Amazon

Best for: A direct engine replacement.

Owners who want a like-for-like swap that matches the original Briggs numbers will find this listing straightforward.

Pros

  • Matches original Briggs part numbers
  • Simple, direct replacement

Cons

  • Fewer brand cross-references than the top pick

View on Amazon

Upgraded Recoil Pull Starter Compatible for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX 575E 600E 625E 140cc 21″ Engines

Upgraded Recoil Pull Starter Compatible for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX 575E 600E 625E 625EX 140cc 21" Engines(Black),Fit for Briggs & Stratton 591139 590588 593961 593959 595355 by Goodicare

Upgraded Recoil Pull Starter Compatible for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX 575E 600E 625E 625EX 140cc 21" Engines(Black),Fit for Briggs & Stratton 591139 590588 593961 593959 595355 by Goodicare

View on Amazon

Best for: Larger 21-inch deck engines.

This option suits owners with a 21-inch deck who run a 600E or 625E engine alongside the 500E family.

Pros

  • Covers 600E and 625E engine models
  • Lists 21-inch deck compatibility

Cons

  • Upgraded designs may not match very old starters exactly

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Match the Engine Model Number

The model number is stamped on the engine shroud, usually on a plate near the carburetor. Compare it against the part number on the starter listing before buying.

Check the Cross-Reference Numbers

Listings that show original Briggs part numbers such as 591139, 593959 or 590588 are easier to verify against your old starter.

Consider the Mower Brand

Many 500E-family engines appear on Craftsman, Troy-Bilt and Husqvarna mowers. Brand-specific listings can save time if your mower carries a non-Briggs badge.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.