Updated November 2026
When a Mac Allister lawn mower won’t start, the cause is usually one of a handful of parts: the recoil starter, the starter solenoid, the starter motor, or the spark and fuel system feeding the engine. This list compares five replacement parts that owners commonly look for when a Mac Allister mower refuses to turn over. The selection criteria were fit with common Briggs and Stratton and Husqvarna-style engines, compatibility with Troy Bilt and similar part numbers, and listing details such as OEM replacement claims and included hardware.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallLawn Mower 961450032 00 and BlackMax BM80919A Recoil StarterView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for electric-start modelsLawn Mower Starter Solenoid 12V 4-Post (146154 Series)View on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for walk-behind decksStens 435-435 Starter SolenoidView on Amazon - 4
Best for Troy Bilt and Briggs engines593959 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 and TB200View on Amazon - 5
Best for hard-to-start engines5742N Starter Motor 16 Teeth for Briggs and StrattonView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Lawn Mower 961450032 00 and BlackMax recoil starter | Pull-start engines | Recoil starter for Husqvarna engines |
| Starter solenoid, 12V 4-post (146154 series) | Electric-start mowers | Copper contacts, quick install |
| Stens 435-435 Starter Solenoid | Walk-behind decks | OEM replacement cross-reference |
| 593959 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt | Troy Bilt and Briggs engines | Pull start assembly |
| 5742N Starter Motor 16 Teeth | Larger Briggs engines | Replaces 41022003 and similar |
Lawn Mower 961450032 00 and BlackMax BM80919A Recoil Starter
for Lawn Mower 961450032 00 and BlackMax BM80919A 2700PSI Pressure Washer Recoil Starter Pull Start for Husqvarna LC221RH 160cc Engine Lawn Mower
Best for: Pull-start engines that won’t recoil or have a broken starter cord
This suits owners whose mower spins freely with no compression pull, a common sign the recoil assembly has failed.
Pros
- Listed as a direct fit for Husqvarna LC221RH 160cc engines
- Pull-start assembly is a straightforward swap for most owners
Cons
- Fit is specific to the listed engine, so match the model number first
Lawn Mower Starter Solenoid 12V 4-Post (146154 Series)
Lawn Mower, fits Husqvrana, Poulan, replaces 532146154, 532145673, 532109946, 894-1221-210, copper contacts, quick install 12V 4-Post Starter Solenoid 146154 145673 for Craftsman 178861
Best for: Electric-start mowers that click but don’t crank
This fits owners whose mower clicks when the key is turned, pointing toward a solenoid rather than the battery.
Pros
- Lists several cross-reference numbers, useful for matching old parts
- Copper contacts and a quick-install design
Cons
- Cross-fit claims should be checked against your part number
Stens 435-435 Starter Solenoid
Best for: Walk-behind decks with a solenoid that has failed
This suits owners who want a replacement described as OEM-style for specific walk-behind decks.
Pros
- Lists multiple OEM cross-reference numbers
- Designed for 52-inch and 60-inch walk-behind decks as listed
Cons
- Narrower fit than universal solenoids; verify the deck size and part number
593959 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 and TB200
593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 TB200 140CC 150CC Lawn Mower Brigs Straton 450E 550EX 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines 593959 Pull Start Assembly
Best for: Troy Bilt and Briggs & Stratton engines with a worn or broken recoil
This fits owners of Troy Bilt-branded mowers who need a full pull-start assembly rather than just a rope.
Pros
- Full assembly, so no need to rebuild the old housing
- Lists many Briggs & Stratton engine codes
Cons
- Engine code must match exactly, or the pulley will not align
5742N Starter Motor 16 Teeth for Briggs and Stratton
5742N Starter Motor 16Teeth Replacement for Briggs and Stratton 1972-2006 7-22 HP, Cub Cadet, Air Cooled, John Deere, 41022003 497595 497594 391423 390838 392749 394805 491766
Best for: Larger Briggs & Stratton engines that crank slowly or not at all
This suits owners of 7–22 HP Briggs and similar engines whose starter motor is weak or seized.
Pros
- Covers a wide range of Briggs & Stratton and John Deere-style engines
- Lists many cross-reference numbers
Cons
- Gear tooth count must match, so count the teeth on your flywheel ring gear
Buying Guide
Identify the failed component first
A click with no crank usually points to the solenoid or battery, while a spinning engine with no pull points to the recoil. Test the battery voltage with a multimeter before buying parts.
Match the part number, not just the model
Mac Allister mowers are often built on engines from other manufacturers. Read the engine code stamped on the block and compare it with the listing’s cross-reference numbers.
Check the engine type and horsepower
Starter motors and recoil assemblies are sized to specific engine families. A 7–22 HP Briggs starter will not fit a small single-cylinder engine.
Consider the cost of a shop visit
Some owners prefer a local small-engine shop for the diagnosis, then buy the part themselves. Ask whether the shop will install a part you supply.
Good picks for this: Recoil starter assembly and Starter solenoid, 12V 4-post
FAQ
Why won’t my Mac Allister lawn mower start even though the engine has fuel?
A mower with fresh fuel can still fail to start if the spark plug is fouled, the air filter is clogged, or the carburetor is gummed up from old gasoline. Checking the spark first is usually the fastest way to narrow down the problem. If the spark is weak or absent, the ignition system or starter component is the more likely culprit.
How do I know if the recoil starter or the starter solenoid is the part that failed?
If the pull cord moves freely but the engine does not turn over at all, the recoil assembly or its pawls may be broken. If you hear a click when you turn the key on an electric-start model but the motor does not crank, the solenoid is a common suspect. Testing the battery voltage first helps rule out a weak battery as the real cause.
Do I need to match the exact part number when replacing a starter component?
Yes, matching the part number is the safest approach because starter parts vary in mounting pattern, terminal layout, and tooth count. Two parts that look similar can have different dimensions that prevent proper engagement. Compare the number printed on your old part against the listing before you order.
Is a recoil starter replacement something a homeowner can do without special tools?
Most recoil starter replacements require only basic hand tools such as a socket set, a screwdriver, and a wrench for the mounting bolts. The job usually involves removing the air cleaner or shroud to access the starter. Take photos during disassembly so you can reassemble the spring and pulley correctly.
Can a dead battery keep a Mac Allister electric-start mower from turning over?
A low or dead battery is a very common reason an electric-start mower will not crank, and it can mimic a failed starter motor or solenoid. Charge or test the battery before replacing any parts. If the battery holds a charge and the motor still does not turn, then the starter components are worth investigating.
When should I take the mower to a repair shop instead of fixing it myself?
Consider a shop visit if you are not comfortable working near the engine, if the problem involves internal engine damage, or if the repair cost approaches the value of the mower. Shop labor can add up quickly, so it helps to diagnose the failed part first. A technician can also confirm the diagnosis if the cause is unclear after basic troubleshooting.
Conclusion
If your Mac Allister mower pulls freely but will not fire, a recoil starter assembly is the most direct fix to consider. For electric-start models that click without cranking, a solenoid or starter motor matching your exact part number is the better choice. Confirm the engine type and part numbers before buying, and test the battery and spark plug first to avoid unnecessary replacements.
Homeowners comfortable with basic hand tools can handle most of these swaps on their own, while anyone unsure of the diagnosis or facing internal engine concerns should consider a repair shop. Matching your mower’s model, engine, and part number closely is the single step that makes the biggest difference in getting the mower running again.
Related reading
- Yardworks Lawn Mower Won't Start After Winter: 6 Fixes That Work
- Yardworks Battery Lawn Mower Won't Start: 7 Causes and Fixes
- Yardman Riding Lawn Mower Won't Start: 7 Causes and Fixes
- Yardman Lawn Mower Won't Start: 8 Causes and Fixes (2026)
- Yard Machines Lawn Mower Won't Start: 7 Causes and Fixes
- Yard Machine Riding Lawn Mower Won't Start: 7 Causes and Fixes

