Updated November 2026

When a murray 450e lawn mower won’t start, the cause is often a worn recoil starter, a damaged start cup or a failed electrical part rather than the engine itself. This guide compares six replacement options sold on Amazon, sorted by which failure they address. Selection was based on listing details, brand reputation and common owner feedback patterns. We did not test these parts ourselves.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines - LawnmoTOP CHOICEBest overallReplacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines – LawnmoView on Amazon
  2. 221" Murray 450E Push Lawn Mower Model MP21450 Recoil Pull StarterTOP CHOICEBest for Murray 21-inch push mowers21" Murray 450E Push Lawn Mower Model MP21450 Recoil Pull StarterView on Amazon
  3. 3#US Starter Parts Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray 450E Lawn Mower 125cc OHVTOP CHOICEBest for 125cc OHV engines#US Starter Parts Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray 450E Lawn Mower 125cc OHVView on Amazon
  4. 4Husqvarna Murray MTD Cub Cadet AYP Poulan Riding Lawn Tractor Ignition Starter SwitchBest for riding mower ignition issuesHusqvarna Murray MTD Cub Cadet AYP Poulan Riding Lawn Tractor Ignition Starter SwitchView on Amazon
  5. 5Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray M22500 Lawn MowerBest for Murray M22500 ownersPull Start Recoil Starter for Murray M22500 Lawn MowerView on Amazon
  6. 6Toro Husqvarna MTD John Deere Starter Solenoid for Murray 7701100MABest for electric start failuresToro Husqvarna MTD John Deere Starter Solenoid for Murray 7701100MAView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Replacement kit for Briggs & Stratton 450E engines Full starter refresh Recoil assembly plus start cups
21″ Murray 450E recoil pull starter Murray 21-inch push mowers Model-specific recoil fit
Pull start recoil starter for Murray 450E 125cc OHV engines Listed for 125cc OHV
Ignition starter switch Riding mower ignition issues Switch replacement for tractors
Pull start recoil starter for Murray M22500 Murray M22500 owners Direct recoil replacement
Starter solenoid Electric start failures Multi-brand solenoid fit

Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines Lawnmower Replacement Kit

Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines - Lawnmower Replacement Kit 6Pcs 593959 Recoil Starter Assembly & 6Pcs 593960 Start Cup

Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines – Lawnmower Replacement Kit 6Pcs 593959 Recoil Starter Assembly & 6Pcs 593960 Start Cup

View on Amazon

Best for: Full starter refresh

This kit suits owners whose pull cord has frayed or whose starter cup has worn smooth after repeated use. It bundles recoil assemblies with start cups, so one order covers the most common wear points.

Pros

  • Includes both recoil assemblies and start cups
  • Covers several related engine series

Cons

  • Compatibility should be checked against your engine model number

View on Amazon

21″ Murray 450E Push Lawn Mower Model MP21450 Recoil Pull Starter

for 21" Murray 450E Push Lawn Mower Model MP21450 Recoil Pull Starter

for 21" Murray 450E Push Lawn Mower Model MP21450 Recoil Pull Starter

View on Amazon

Best for: Murray 21-inch push mowers

Aimed at owners of the 21-inch Murray 450E push model, this starter is the direct replacement when the cord pulls freely but the engine never turns over.

Pros

  • Model-specific fit for the 21-inch deck
  • Straightforward swap with basic hand tools

Cons

  • Only suits the 21-inch model

View on Amazon

#US Starter Parts Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray 450E Lawn Mower 125cc OHV

#US Starter Parts Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray 450E Lawn Mower 125cc OHV - (diepparts#131026.09846)

#US Starter Parts Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray 450E Lawn Mower 125cc OHV – (diepparts#131026.09846)

View on Amazon

Best for: 125cc OHV engines

This option is listed for 125cc overhead-valve engines, making it a fit for owners who have confirmed their engine displacement before ordering.

Pros

  • Listed specifically for 125cc OHV engines
  • Complete recoil starter assembly

Cons

  • Requires confirming displacement and part number first

View on Amazon

Husqvarna Murray MTD Cub Cadet AYP Poulan Riding Lawn Tractor Ignition Starter Switch

Husqvarna Murray MTD Cub Cadet AYP Poulan Riding Lawn Tractor Mower 430-674 140301 532140301 574455401 092556 092556MA BlueStars 725-1717 925-1717 Ignition Starter Switch - For Craftsman

Husqvarna Murray MTD Cub Cadet AYP Poulan Riding Lawn Tractor Mower 430-674 140301 532140301 574455401 092556 092556MA BlueStars 725-1717 925-1717 Ignition Starter Switch – For Craftsman

View on Amazon

Best for: Riding mower ignition issues

If the key turns but the mower gives only a click or nothing at all, a failed ignition switch is a common culprit. This switch is listed for a wide range of riding tractors. A related read: 7 Best Replacement Parts for a Flipped Lawn Mower That Won't Start (2026).

Pros

  • Broad compatibility across riding tractor brands
  • Addresses a common electrical failure point

Cons

  • Wiring must be matched to your specific harness

View on Amazon

Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray M22500 Lawn Mower

Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray M22500 Lawn Mower 961140029 03

Pull Start Recoil Starter for Murray M22500 Lawn Mower 961140029 03

View on Amazon

Best for: Murray M22500 owners

This recoil starter targets the M22500 model and is a practical choice when the original starter has broken or stripped its internal spring.

Pros

  • Designed for a specific Murray model
  • Direct bolt-on replacement

Cons

  • Limited to the M22500 model family

View on Amazon

Toro Husqvarna MTD John Deere Starter Solenoid for Murray 7701100MA

24285 424285 Toro 111674 6120-430-0500 53490009 Husqvarna 539101714 MTD 725-0530 725-0771 925-0771 Trombetta John Deere BlueStars 435-097 Starter Solenoid - For Murray 7701100MA 1002004MA

24285 424285 Toro 111674 6120-430-0500 53490009 Husqvarna 539101714 MTD 725-0530 725-0771 925-0771 Trombetta John Deere BlueStars 435-097 Starter Solenoid – For Murray 7701100MA 1002004MA

View on Amazon

Best for: Electric start failures

When the mower clicks but the starter motor does not engage, the solenoid is a likely suspect. This part is listed across several brands and Murray part numbers.

Pros

  • Multi-brand listing with Murray part number matches
  • Addresses a common electric start failure

Cons

  • Confirm the part number matches your mower before buying

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Identify the failure before you buy

A pull cord that retracts without resistance points to the recoil starter, while a click with no cranking usually points to the solenoid or battery. Matching the symptom to the part saves an unnecessary order.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.