Updated November 2026
A Troy Bilt Bronco lawn mower won’t start when the starter motor, solenoid or recoil assembly has worn out, and the right replacement part depends on which component has failed. This list compares seven replacement starters and related parts, based on listing details, compatibility notes and common owner feedback. Selection criteria include model fit, engine compatibility, tooth count on starter gears and whether the part is a direct replacement.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallfor Troy Bilt 42 inch Bronco, Pony Riding Lawn Mower Tractors 17.5HP 1View on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for tooth-count matching14 Tooth Starter Motor for 42 Cut Troy Bilt Bronco, Pony Lawn Mower TractorsView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for Cub Cadet and MTD-family solenoid kitsGenuine OEM Trombetta 12V Starter Solenoid Kit for Cub Cadet and MTD Zero Turn MowersView on Amazon - 4
Best for TB110 and TB200 recoil starts593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 TB200 Lawn Mower Pull Start AssemblyView on Amazon - 5
Best for solenoid-only replacement725-06153A Starter Solenoid Relay for MTD Troy Bilt Cub Cadet TractorsView on Amazon - 6
Best for multi-brand compatibilityBriggs and Stratton Motor Starter 593934 693551 12HP-21HP Fit 31C707 3View on Amazon - 7
Best for tiller-style recoil replacementPull‑Recoil Starter Assembly – Fits Troy Bilt Bronco Garden Tillers (MView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
Quick Comparison
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Troy Bilt 42 inch Bronco starter replacement | Overall starter swap | 14 teeth, Intek OHV fit |
| 14 Tooth Starter Motor for 42 Cut Troy Bilt Bronco | Tooth-count matching | 14-tooth gear specified |
| Trombetta 12V Starter Solenoid Kit | Cub Cadet and MTD-family solenoids | OEM-style kit |
| Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 TB200 | TB110 and TB200 recoil starts | Pull start assembly |
| Starter Solenoid Relay for MTD Troy Bilt | Solenoid-only replacement | Multiple cross-reference numbers |
| Briggs and Stratton Motor Starter 593934 | Multi-brand compatibility | 12HP–21HP engine range |
| Pull-Recoil Starter Assembly for Bronco tillers | Tiller-style recoil replacement | Model-number fit listed |
Troy Bilt 42 inch Bronco, Pony Riding Lawn Mower Tractors 17.5HP–20HP 14 Teeth Starter Replacement
for Troy Bilt 42 inch Bronco, Pony Riding Lawn Mower Tractors 17.5HP 18HP 18.5HP 19HP 19.5HP 20HP, 14 Teeth Starter Replacement for Briggs and Stratton Intek IC OHV Engine
Best for: Overall starter swap
A good fit for owners of 42-inch Bronco and Pony riding mowers with Briggs and Stratton Intek OHV engines who need a direct starter motor replacement.
Pros
- Lists a 14-tooth gear that matches the stated engine range
- Covers a wide span of horsepower ratings
Cons
- Fit depends on confirming your exact engine model
14 Tooth Starter Motor for 42 Cut Troy Bilt Bronco, Pony Lawn Mower Tractors
14 Tooth Starter Motor for 42 Cut Troy Bilt Bronco, Pony Lawn Mower Tractors Replace Briggs Stratton CMXGRAM1130037 CMXGRAM1130036 13AN77XS093 Intek IC OHV Engine
Best for: Tooth-count matching
Suits owners who have already confirmed the flywheel uses a 14-tooth ring and want a starter that lists matching Briggs and Stratton part numbers.
Pros
- Cross-references several Briggs and Stratton part numbers
- Clear engine family listing
Cons
- Tooth count must be verified before ordering
Genuine OEM Trombetta 12V Starter Solenoid Kit for Cub Cadet and MTD Zero Turn Mowers
Genuine OEM Trombetta 12V Starter Solenoid Kit for Cub Cadet 725-06153A XT1 XT2 Enduro ZT1 54 42 RZT, Replaces MTD Troy Bilt Craftsman Zero Turn Riding Lawn Mower Tractor 762-1261-211-51
Best for: Cub Cadet and MTD-family solenoid kits
Best for owners of MTD-built Troy Bilt zero-turn and Cub Cadet models who need a solenoid rather than a full starter motor.
Pros
- Lists OEM-style construction and multiple cross-reference numbers
- Covers a broad set of MTD-family models
Cons
- Designed for zero-turn and riding platforms, not walk-behind units
593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 TB200 Lawn Mower Pull Start Assembly
593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Troy Bilt TB110 TB200 140CC 150CC Lawn Mower Brigs Straton 450E 550EX 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines 593959 Pull Start Assembly
Best for: TB110 and TB200 recoil starts
Fits owners whose mower pulls to start but the rope does not retract or engage, pointing to a worn recoil assembly.
Pros
- Lists several engine model codes
- Complete pull-start assembly rather than individual springs
Cons
- Fit is model-specific, so check the engine code first
725-06153A Starter Solenoid Relay for MTD Troy Bilt Cub Cadet Tractors
725-06153A 725-06153 Starter Solenoid Relay for Riding Lawn Mower Fit for MTD Troy Bilt Cub Cadet XT2 ZT1 RZT Tractor and for Craftsman Zero Turn Ride Mower Replaces 532192507 582042801 435-325
Best for: Solenoid-only replacement
A practical choice when the engine cranks slowly or clicks but the starter motor itself seems sound.
Pros
- Lists multiple original-equipment cross-reference numbers
- Lower-cost swap compared with a full starter
Cons
- Does not fix a worn starter motor or gear

