Updated November 2026

If your Murray 500E lawn mower won’t start, a worn or broken recoil starter is one of the most common culprits, and replacing it is often a practical repair. This guide compares six replacement starter options for the 500E series, based on listing details, compatibility notes and common owner feedback. Selection criteria: model compatibility with the 500E or 11A-A2BF758, completeness of the kit, and ease of installation.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Recoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21" 500E Push Mower 11A-A2BF758 Pull Starter 500ETOP CHOICEBest overallRecoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21" 500E Push Mower 11A-A2BF758 Pull Starter 500EView on Amazon
  2. 2Recoil Pull Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758TOP CHOICEBest for a direct model matchRecoil Pull Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758View on Amazon
  3. 3Lawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement for 593959 300E 450E 500E 550ETOP CHOICEBest for multi-model compatibilityLawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement for 593959 300E 450E 500E 550EView on Amazon
  4. 4Lawn Mower Starter, Pull Start Assembly, Durable Plastic Build, with Weatherproof GuardBest for weather exposureLawn Mower Starter, Pull Start Assembly, Durable Plastic Build, with Weatherproof GuardView on Amazon
  5. 5#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758Best for a parts-number search#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758View on Amazon
  6. 6for 593960 Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit for Briggs Stratton Murray 300E 450E 500EBest for a full rope rebuildfor 593960 Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit for Briggs Stratton Murray 300E 450E 500EView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Recoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21″ 500E Overall replacement Model-specific 500E fit
Recoil Pull Starter for Murray 21″ 500E Matching by model number Listed for 11A-A2BF758
Lawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement Multi-model compatibility Covers several 300E–625E models
Lawn Mower Starter Pull Start Assembly Exposed or wet conditions Weatherproof guard included
#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter Parts-number cross-check Keyed to a parts reference
Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit Worn rope or drum Rope and drum components

Recoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21″ 500E Push Mower 11A-A2BF758 Pull Starter 500E

Recoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21" 500E Push Mower 11A-A2BF758 Pull Starter 500E

Recoil Rewind Pull Starter Murr-ay 21" 500E Push Mower 11A-A2BF758 Pull Starter 500E

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall replacement

This suits owners who want a starter listed specifically for the 21-inch 500E push mower and want to avoid guessing at fit.

Pros

  • Listed directly for the 500E push mower
  • Model-specific fit reduces ordering mistakes

Cons

  • Installation still requires removing the old starter first

View on Amazon

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray 21″ 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758

Recoil Pull Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758

View on Amazon

Best for: Matching by model number

A good fit for owners who have already read the model plate and want a direct match to 11A-A2BF758.

Pros

  • Clear model-number listing
  • Straightforward replacement of the pull assembly

Cons

  • Fit depends on confirming the exact model number first

View on Amazon

Lawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement for 593959 300E 450E 500E 550E

Lawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement for 593959 300E 450E 500E 550E 550EX 575EX 600E 625E Lawn Mowers

Lawn Mower Starter Plastic Pull Start Replacement for 593959 300E 450E 500E 550E 550EX 575EX 600E 625E Lawn Mowers

View on Amazon

Best for: Multi-model compatibility

Useful if you own more than one Murray-style mower and want a single starter that covers several series.

Pros

  • Lists several 300E through 625E models
  • Plastic build keeps weight low

Cons

  • Broad compatibility means checking your exact model before ordering

View on Amazon

Lawn Mower Starter, Pull Start Assembly, Durable Plastic Build, with Weatherproof Guard

Lawn Mower Starter, Pull Start Assembly, Durable Plastic Build, Quick Install Replacement, with Screws, for 300E 450E 500E 550E, Weatherproof Guard

Lawn Mower Starter, Pull Start Assembly, Durable Plastic Build, Quick Install Replacement, with Screws, for 300E 450E 500E 550E, Weatherproof Guard

View on Amazon

Best for: Weather exposure

For mowers stored outdoors or often used in damp grass, where a guarded assembly may hold up better.

Pros

  • Includes screws for quick installation
  • Weatherproof guard shields the mechanism

Cons

  • Guard adds some bulk around the starter housing

View on Amazon

#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 21″ 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758

#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758 - (diepparts#131026.08359)

#US Starter Parts Pull Recoil Starter for Murray 21" 500E Push Mower Model 11A-A2BF758 – (diepparts#131026.08359)

View on Amazon

Best for: Parts-number cross-check

Best for owners who want to confirm a parts reference against the 500E model before buying.

Pros

  • Lists the 11A-A2BF758 model number
  • Includes a parts reference for cross-checking

Cons

  • Listing title is dense and takes care to read

View on Amazon

for 593960 Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit for Briggs Stratton Murray 300E 450E 500E

for 593960 Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit for Briggs Stratton Murray 300E 450E 500E

for 593960 Starter Flywheel Drum Rope Kit for Briggs Stratton Murray 300E 450E 500E

View on Amazon

Best for: Full rope rebuild

Suited to mowers where the rope is frayed or the drum is worn, rather than the whole housing being broken.

Pros

  • Covers rope and drum components together
  • Useful when the starter housing is still sound

Cons

  • Requires more disassembly than a full starter swap

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Confirm your exact model number

The 500E series includes several listings, and the model number on the deck or engine plate tells you which starter will fit. Matching this number before ordering prevents most fit problems.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.