Updated November 2026

A briggs and stratton 500e lawn mower won’t start for many owners because the recoil starter has worn out, the pull cord has snapped, or the starter pawls have failed to engage the flywheel. When that happens, a replacement recoil starter assembly is often the most direct fix. The picks below were chosen by checking listing details, compatibility notes for the 450E, 500E and 550E engine families, and the kind of owner feedback that usually points to a good fit or a problem.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550EXTOP CHOICEBest overallPull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550EXView on Amazon
  2. 2Recoil Starter Assembly 593959 for Briggs and Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex SeriesBest for a single-part swapRecoil Starter Assembly 593959 for Briggs and Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex SeriesView on Amazon
  3. 3Recoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc EngineBest for multi-model ownersRecoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc EngineView on Amazon
  4. 4Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines - LawnmoBest for a full refreshReplacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines – LawnmoView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 (Troy-Bilt/Craftsman fit) Best overall Wide engine compatibility
Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 (08P502 series) Single-part swap Replaces 595355 and 593961
Recoil Starter 591139 (575EX and Husqvarna fit) Multi-model owners Covers 140cc engines
Replacement Kit 6Pcs Recoil Starter and Start Cup Full refresh Includes start cups

Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550EX

08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200, Craftsman M110/M115 Mowers Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX

08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engines, Fits Troy-Bilt TB110/TB115/TB200, Craftsman M110/M115 Mowers Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550EX

View on Amazon

Best for: Best overall

This assembly is aimed at owners who want one part that is listed across several related engine and mower brands, including Troy-Bilt and Craftsman models.

Pros

  • Lists a broad set of compatible part numbers
  • Covers the 450E, 500E and 550EX families

Cons

  • Confirm your engine model number before ordering

View on Amazon

Recoil Starter Assembly 593959 for Briggs and Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series

593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engine Lawn Mower, Replace 595355 590588 593961

593959 Recoil Starter Assembly 591139 for Briggs & Stratton 450e 500e 550e 550ex Series 08P502 093J02 09P602 09P702 Engine Lawn Mower, Replace 595355 590588 593961

View on Amazon

Best for: Best for a single-part swap

Suited to owners who know their engine is in the 500E or 550E family and want a straightforward replacement without extra pieces.

Pros

  • Lists the 593959 and 591139 numbers directly in the title
  • Cross-references several older part numbers

Cons

  • Installation still requires removing the old starter and clearing the flywheel area

View on Amazon

Recoil Starter for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine

591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine, Pull Start for Troy-Bilt TB100 TB110 TB200, Husqvarna LC221A HU550FH HU625AWD, Craftsman M105 M110 M210 Lawn Mower

591139 Recoil Starter for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575EX 140cc Engine, Pull Start for Troy-Bilt TB100 TB110 TB200, Husqvarna LC221A HU550FH HU625AWD, Craftsman M105 M110 M210 Lawn Mower

View on Amazon

Best for: Best for multi-model owners

A good option for owners who also run Husqvarna or Craftsman mowers and want one part number that spans several engine types.

Pros

  • Lists 140cc engine compatibility alongside 575EX
  • Fits a range of Husqvarna and Craftsman models

Cons

  • Broad compatibility means matching the part number to your engine matters

View on Amazon

Replacement for Briggs and Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines Lawnmower Replacement Kit 6Pcs

Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines - Lawnmower Replacement Kit 6Pcs 593959 Recoil Starter Assembly & 6Pcs 593960 Start Cup

Replacement for Briggs & Stratton 450E 500E 550E 575E Engines – Lawnmower Replacement Kit 6Pcs 593959 Recoil Starter Assembly & 6Pcs 593960 Start Cup

View on Amazon

Best for: Best for a full refresh

Aimed at owners who suspect the start cups and the recoil assembly are both worn, since the kit bundles six of each.

Pros

  • Includes both recoil starter assemblies and start cups
  • Useful as a spare set

Cons

  • Extra pieces you may not need for a simple cord or pawl repair

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Match the part number to your engine

Check the model and code stamped on your engine shroud before ordering. Several part numbers, such as 593959 and 591139, appear across related engines, but cross-references are not identical.

Decide between a single part and a kit

If only the rope has broken, a single assembly is enough. If the start cup or pawls also look worn, a kit can save a second trip to the parts counter.

Check the mower’s other components

A new starter will not help if the spark plug is fouled or the fuel is stale. Work through the basics before assuming the recoil is the problem; the Briggs and Stratton Lawn Mower Won't Start: 6 Replacement Parts Compared (2026) guide covers the common alternatives.

Consider the engine’s age and service history

Older engines with repeated starter failures may point to a worn crankshaft or a flywheel key problem, which a new starter cannot fix.

Good picks for this: Pull Start Assembly 593959 591139 and Recoil Starter Assembly 593959

FAQ

Can I replace the recoil starter myself?

Yes, most owners can swap the assembly with basic hand tools after disconnecting the spark plug wire. If you are unsure, consult a small-engine repair professional.

Why won’t my briggs and stratton 500e lawn mower won’t start even with a new rope?

The starter pawls or the start cup may also be worn, and the engine may need fuel or spark checks.

Do I need the start cup if I buy a starter?

Not always, but if the cup is cracked or worn, replacing it at the same time prevents the new starter from slipping.

Conclusion

For a broad match across related engines, the Troy-Bilt and Craftsman compatible assembly is a sound place to start. Owners who want a single swap should choose the 593959 assembly, multi-model owners should consider the 575EX-compatible starter, and anyone replacing several worn parts will get the most from the six-piece kit.

Graham Fisher

About Graham Fisher

Graham Fisher is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our lawn mowers guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.